WBS Budget in SAP: How to Check It and Fix Budget Exceeded Errors

·5 min read
WBS Budget in SAP: How to Check It and Fix Budget Exceeded Errors

To check the budget of a WBS element in SAP, run report S_ALR_87013558, which shows the budget, actual costs, commitments and assigned values side by side, or display the budget with CJ31. If a posting is refused because the budget is exceeded, compare the budget with the assigned value, not with the actual costs. This guide explains what counts as assigned, why two screens can show different figures, and how to solve the error.

Advertisement

Three ways to check a WBS budget

UseTo seeGood for
S_ALR_87013558Budget, actual, commitment, remaining plan and assignedA quick overview of a project
CJ31The budget per WBS element, and the availability control analysisUnderstanding why a posting was blocked
CJI3 and CJI5The actual and commitment line itemsFinding the documents behind the figures

For the basics, such as the original budget, supplements and transfers, see budgeting in SAP PS.

What counts as assigned

Availability control compares the budget with the assigned value of the WBS element that carries the budget. According to SAP Help, the assigned value is calculated like this:

CountsDoes not count
Actual costs of the WBS element that carries the budget, including statistical actual costsCosts planned directly on the WBS element
Actual costs and commitments of the WBS elements below it, if they do not carry a budget themselvesCosts on an exempt cost element
Commitments, such as purchase requisitions and purchase ordersBusiness transactions outside the groups checked by the tolerance limits
For assigned networks and orders, the higher of the plan and the actual costs plus commitmentsRevenues
Costs received by settlementCredits from a settlement to an object without budget control, such as a cost center

The last line surprises many users: if you settle costs from a WBS element to a cost center, the budget is not given back. It is given back only if the receiver is itself controlled by a budget.

Worked example

A WBS element has a budget of 100,000. Only the following is assigned to it:

Stacked bar: a budget of 100,000 with 40,000 actual costs, 25,000 purchase orders and 30,000 for the network, leaving 5,000 available

ItemAmountAssigned
Actual costs posted on the WBS element40,00040,000
Open purchase orders25,00025,000
Network: plan 30,000, actual and commitments 15,000the higher one30,000
Total assigned95,000
Available5,000

A new purchase order of 8,000 would bring the assigned value to 103,000. It can be blocked, although the actual costs on the WBS element are only 40,000.

What happens when the budget is exceeded

The reaction depends on the tolerance limits, which are defined in customizing per controlling area, budget profile and activity group. According to SAP Learning, three actions are possible:

  • Warning: the user sees a message and can continue.

  • Warning and email to the person responsible for the project.

  • Error: the posting is refused.

The tolerance limit is a percentage of the budget, an absolute amount, or both. This is why an error may appear before or after 100% of the budget is used. The budget profile also decides whether the check is made against the current or the released budget, and against overall or annual values.

Advertisement

How to solve a budget exceeded error

The message usually belongs to class BP, for example BP603 or BP604. Work through these steps:

  1. Read the message. Note the WBS element and the amount. The element named in the message is the one that carries the budget, which may be above the one you are posting to.

  2. Compare budget and assigned for that element with S_ALR_87013558, then look at the availability control analysis in CJ31.

  3. Check the year. If availability control uses annual values, the overall budget may be sufficient and the current year not.

  4. Check the release. If control is based on released budget, the budget may exist but not be released (CJ32).

  5. Look for old commitments in CJI5. Purchase orders that will never be delivered or invoiced still use the budget.

  6. Check the networks and orders. A plan that is too high keeps budget reserved, as in the example above.

CauseSolution
The budget is really too lowRequest a supplement (CJ36, CJ37) or a transfer (CJ34)
The budget sits on another WBS elementTransfer it with CJ34, or distribute it with CJ30
The budget is not releasedRelease it with CJ32
Old purchase orders or requisitions are still openClose them: final delivery, final invoice, or deletion of the item
The network or order plan is too highAdjust the plan, or complete the finished activities and orders
The costs were posted to the wrong elementCorrect the posting
A cost element should not consume budgetAsk your consultant whether it should be an exempt cost element
The figures look wrongSee the next section

Avoid deactivating availability control to let one document through. While it is off, nobody is warned about any other overrun.

Why CJ31 and S_ALR_87013558 can differ

It is a known situation: SAP describes it in KBA 2491647 (the full text requires an SAP login). Before opening an incident, check these points:

  • Selection: same version, period, fiscal year, currency and database profile in the report.

  • Level: availability control works on the element that carries the budget, while the report shows every level.

  • Exempt cost elements: excluded by availability control, but they can be included in the report.

  • Settlement: credits may reduce the costs in a report without giving back budget.

  • Data: the project information database used by reports can be rebuilt with CJEN, and availability control with CJBN.

Run CJEN and CJBN only with your consultant or support team, outside working hours if possible, because other users should not post to the project in the meantime.

Good practices

  • Decide early at which WBS level budgets are controlled, and do not mix levels without a reason.

  • Set a warning below 100%, for example at 90%, so that project managers can react before postings are blocked.

  • Review open commitments every month, before requesting a supplement.

  • Close finished networks and orders, so that they stop reserving budget.

Frequently asked questions

How do I check a WBS budget in SAP?

With report S_ALR_87013558 for an overview, or CJ31 for the budget of each WBS element.

Does cost planning consume the budget?

Not when costs are planned directly on the WBS element, for example with CJ40. The plan of assigned networks and orders can consume it. See cost planning.

Does a purchase requisition consume the budget?

It can, because it creates a commitment, provided that this activity group is included in the tolerance limits.

Which table contains the budget of a WBS element?

BPGE for overall values and BPJA for annual values. See SAP PS tables.

Advertisement
Looking for the reference pages? See the SAP PS transaction codes, database tables and module overview.